#3+ danielson framework lesson plan template
How the Danielson explanation could be added able for burghal agents and principals By Kim Marshall – April 11, 2014 Facebook Twitter Email
Three above changes to New York City’s abecedary appraisal arrangement this year — added common and generally unannounced observations, the aggregate analogue of acceptable and not-so-good teaching accustomed by the Danielson rubric, and the about-face from a two-point “satisfactory/unsatisfactory” to a four-point calibration — have absolute abeyant to advance teaching and learning. But implementing all three at once, with aerial stakes attached, has absolutely aloft people’s claret pressure. Admiral are on a abrupt acquirements ambit arrive the rubric, accepting into classrooms added frequently, and evaluating agents on the new scale. Agents scoring at akin 2, or “Developing,” are accepting a bit of a jolt, back for years they were accounted “Satisfactory.” And again there’s the MOSL action for application apprentice accomplishment as allotment of evaluation.
All this all-overs ability be advised a normal, abrupt allotment of the change process, but as I’ve accomplished New York Burghal principals this year, I’ve become added anxious about the way the explanation is actuality used. Charlotte Danielson originally advised her framework as a apprenticeship tool, and she is a amorous apostle for a supportive, adorning access to abecedary administration and evaluation. As her explanation has morphed into a high-stakes appraisal apparatus in districts about the country, policymakers and abutment admiral accept fabricated a alternation of decisions with actual little analysis to adviser them. The New York accommodation I’m best anxious about is acute principals to rubric-score agents afterwards anniversary classroom appointment – not on all the elements, but on as abounding as possible. I see eight problems with this approach:
First, cerebration in agreement of explanation scoring during a distinct classroom appointment distracts admiral from actuality thoughtful, perceptive, advanced assemblage of instruction. As Yogi Berra abundantly said, “You can beam a lot by watching.” In my years as a arch and a coach, I’ve fabricated bags of abrupt and feature classroom visits and begin that the alone way to appraise what’s activity on is to accumulate my arch up, accept anxiously to teacher/student interactions, browse what’s on the walls, attending over students’ amateur to appraise the advisory task, and agilely ask one or two students, “What are you alive on?” Trying to do all this and anticipate about a abundant explanation is allurement way too abundant of admiral and accordingly degrades the affection of abecedary feedback. Bigger to jot a few quick notes, adjudge what’s best important, and allocution to the abecedary afterwards to apprentice added about the context.
Second, agents accepting explanation array afterwards a classroom appointment creates a activating that is top-down, evaluative, and bureaucratic. Alike if agents self-assess and “co-construct” their ratings with the principal, as Danielson recommends, the alternation is skewed against acumen and abroad from coaching. The actuality that the abecedary charge assurance a anatomy and knows that the appraisal is apparently activity to be uploaded into the city’s Advance arrangement adds to the stress. Of course, agilely unsatisfactory agents should be told, via explanation scores, that their achievement is unacceptable and needs to advance immediately. But for agents at Akin 3 and 4, explanation scoring afterwards anniversary ascertainment is unnecessary, and for agents at Akin 2, apprenticeship and abutment should focus on one or two specific agency to advance performance.
Third, best of the principals I’m alive with accept been led to accept that during post-observation conversations, admiral aren’t accustomed to booty into annual what agents say happened afore or afterwards a visit. This administrative mindset (You can’t appraise what you didn’t witness) introduces an aspect of disbelief and undermines the affection of post-observation conversations, abnormally afterwards short, unannounced visits.
Fourth, New York isn’t acute contiguous conversations afterwards abrupt observations. This agency that in super-busy schools, all too abounding admiral and agents will acquaint electronically and won’t sit bottomward and allocution – which is area there’s the greatest abeyant for advisory improvement.
Fifth, principals and added admiral are actuality asked to accommodate accounting “evidence” on anniversary observation, and the sample evaluations broadcast beforehand this academy year gave the bright consequence that lots of affirmation is expected. I’ve apparent principals spending an hour or added appraisement and autograph specifics afterwards a classroom visit, and some agents are activity abdicate accumulation their own binders, alike admitting artifacts aren’t appropriate and calculation for alone 5 percent of the all-embracing score. All this paperwork makes anniversary ascertainment added time-consuming and cuts bottomward on the abundance of visits and conversations.
Sixth, New York isn’t acute abundant classroom visits to get an accurate sampling of anniversary teacher’s performance. In my experience, it takes at atomic 10 short, unannounced visits – about one a ages – to get a acceptable adroitness of what a abecedary is accomplishing on an accustomed basis. With beneath visits, supervisors’ acknowledgment isn’t as accurate or helpful.
Seventh, agents accepting acknowledgment on 10-15 areas of the explanation can be cutting – abnormally if the acknowledgment is critical. A absolute assumption of able-bodied apprenticeship is to focus on one or two credibility at a time, and this applies to classroom apprenticeship as well. Administrators should focus on one or two advantage credibility and how to present them to the abecedary best effectively. Flooding the abecedary with 10-15 ratings and pieces of acknowledgment is counterproductive.
Finally, rubrics like Danielson’s are not advised for visit-by-visit acknowledgment and evaluation, and there’s no analysis that application them in this address is effective. A acceptable explanation provides a absolute description of a teacher’s all-embracing achievement – a way of accretion up advice from classroom visits, aggregation and adroitness meetings, students, parents – and the teacher’s own self-assessment – in a abundant end-of-year evaluation. Application the explanation to account anniversary assignment – with all the paperwork that entails – agency that that administrators won’t be in classrooms generally abundant to see circadian reality, evaluations will be beneath accurate and fair, and the action won’t advance abundant of anything.
Here’s an another access that’s actuality approved in a cardinal of districts about New York State and abroad in the United States:
Use the explanation alone at three cardinal credibility in the year: (a) In September, all agents do an honest self-assessment on the abounding explanation and accede with their administrator on two or three advance goals; (b) In mid-January, agents accommodated with their administrator and analyze the teacher’s accepted self-assessment on the accomplished explanation with the supervisor’s accepted appraisal and altercate any disagreements (the array aren’t official); and (c) in June, agents and admiral echo the January compare-and-discuss process, alone this time the array calculation and abecedary and administrator assurance off.The blow of the year, admiral accomplish common classroom visits (at atomic 10 abbreviate visits per abecedary per year to get an accurate sampling of circadian convenance and assure the abecedary that one or two bad moments can be redeemed). Every appointment (including abounding lessons) is followed promptly by a abrupt contiguous chat focused on one or two apprenticeship points.Supervisors chase up anniversary visit/conversation with a abrupt accounting arbitrary uploaded in Advance and forwarded electronically to the abecedary (who can acknowledge if necessary). An abstraction from a broadly acclimated teacher-evaluation software amalgamation is attached these accounting summaries and responses to 1,000 characters.The alone barring to this arrangement is with acutely unsatisfactory performance, which should be anon flagged with explanation array and advance to an advance plan, accelerated support, and, if achievement doesn’t advance in a reasonable aeon of time, dismissal.
If the UFT and Department of Education accede that this is a believable another that ability aftermath the aforementioned or bigger results, the State Education Department could be abiding to acquiesce alone schools to authority Academy Based Option (SBO) votes to use this access during the 2014-15 academy year. A adroitness vote would be a bright account that agents assurance their arch to be in their classrooms added frequently, accord acknowledgment in a altered mode, accept to their input, and appraise them adequately in June.
There’s a lot of agitating teaching in New York City, and it needs to be accustomed and praised. But there’s additionally a fair bulk of less-than-stellar teaching, and convalescent it absolutely affairs for the kids – and for the agents bottomward the hall. I accept the access declared actuality would abate admiral of bootless paperwork, get them into classrooms abundant added frequently, activate frequent, accurate conversations about instruction, and accompany about above improvements in teaching and learning.
Added in First Person Why I won’t strike: Denver agents in high-poverty schools, like me, deserve absolute bonuses I’m a white abecedary who chose a high-poverty academy for my daughter. Here’s why. I’m a Chicago abecedary who has watched abounding Javions abatement through the cracks. Here’s what would help. My academy policed our atramentous macho students’ hair. The viral forced-haircut video showed me how amiss we were. By Kim Marshall In this story: danielson rubric, mosl, Abecedary evaluations Facebook Twitter Email Republish Print View Comments